Back to main Back to Advanced level Back to Food Supply

Environmental aspects of the global trade in foodstuffs.

The potential for sustainable food supplies.

Think about it!

Post World War 2 saw a massive intensification of agriculture in the Western world, and these intensive industrial farm practises have spread globally through the transfer of technology, the emergence of new farming superpowers such as Brazil (see notes on Brazil’s approach to farming, from Jimmy’s global harvest here) and the use of the Green revolution.  Indeed, farming is truly globalised, and you can read more about the factors behind that here. 

  

However, this globalisation of farming, the use of the free market and the transport of food over great distances has huge consequences for the environment.  In many ways modern industrial farming is unsustainable, and the search for sustainability in farming is on.  This also has to balance with the need to feed an ever increasing number of people as population increases, can we avoid a Malthusian catastrophe?  Remember Sustainable Development as a concept means "development that meets the needs of the present (generations) without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs."  (Brundtland commission 1983)

The idea would be that humans do not exceed the carrying capacity of the Earth, and that in the context of food supply we produce our food in a manner that nourishes all of the people on planet Earth well without limiting future generations ability to feed themselves by using up natural resources or damaging the environment we use to produce our food.  We need to appreciate that there needs to be availability of food to an appropriate level for the population should be secure, long term and without causing damage to the environment. This poses huge issues, because our current method of agricultural production to meet food supply poses the following environmental problems;

Food miles

Food miles are a basic way of showing how far our food travels to get to us.  The amount of food miles is increasing for each family in the UK.  The increase in food miles poses significant problems to the environment because of the energy required to transport the food.  This is becoming increasingly important as increasing quantities of our food are now being air freighted, the worst type of transport for air pollution.  The number of food miles also varies per food type, and we import 89% of our fruit.  We also transport food stuffs that can be grown here in the UK, including potatoes. This is surprising, and according to the British Potato Council, the UK imports 350,000 tonnes of potatoes a year, and that includes during potato season.  Calculate your food miles here.  Kenya benefits massively (24% of GDP and 50% of export earnings come from agriculture) from its export of chillies, sugar snaps, green beans, flowers and baby corn, but is it environmentally ethical and socially ethical (in a food shortage country) to do so?

 The graphic below shows this point well;

Click for a cleaner image

Carbon footprint

Food miles therefore contribute to the carbon footprint of our food.  The transport types used output huge quantities of greenhouse gasses such as Carbon Dioxide and Nitrous Oxides.  However, transport is only part of the carbon footprint of our food and this has a direct impact on our environment.  Other items produce carbon dioxide, including packaging, especially plastic packaging, the retail spaces that sell our food (in the form of their electricity use, heating, refrigeration etc), agricultural production of carbon, food use etc.  This is wonderfully demonstrated on the graph below.

Source

Use of chemical fertilisers

Fertilisers enhance soil chemistry by introducing nutrients deficient in or lacking in soils. Fertilizers often contain a mixture of nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium in varying quantities, depending on the application. All of these chemicals occur naturally in the environment.  They can have a negative impact upon the environment.  When excess nitrites and nitrates enter aquatic or water ecosystems, an increase in the ammonia cycle occurs resulting in excessive ammonia in the water, which can kill aquatic plants and organisms.  In addition, excessive phosphorus in aquatic ecosystems causes algal blooms, which in turn create a cycle whereby dissolved oxygen is depleted, resulting in plant and fish kills.

Use of chemical pesticides, fungicides and insecticides

Pesticides, fungicides and insecticides are used to control those organisms that cause damage to agricultural products and would lower yields if left unchecked.  Many chemicals are also sprayed, and this means that many of these chemicals end up in a location other than the intended destination.  Over 98% of sprayed insecticides and 95% of herbicides reach a destination other than their target species, including non-target species, air, water, bottom sediments, and food.  Pesticides can also contaminate unintended land and water when they are sprayed aerially or allowed to run off fields, or when they escape from production sites and storage tanks or are inappropriately discarded.  Many of these chemicals are persistent soil contaminants, and pesticides have also been strongly linked with the decline of the Honey bee.

Birds have also suffered, and it is estimated that populations of ten different bird species declined by 10 million breeding individuals between 1979 and 1999, a phenomenon thought to have resulted from loss of plant and invertebrate species on which the birds feed. A good example of this is Juazeiro, Bahio state.  This is one of the driest parts of Brazil in the North East, but irrigation has allowed farmers to transform the area.  The food produced is fruit and vegetables for the global market. The farmers try to meet the demand for all year round fruit, even out of season.  There is a mango farm here renowned for innovation, it produces 3 million kilos of mangos per year for Europe, the US and Canada.  There is so much sun they have to spray lime to protect the fruit in the consistent sunshine.  The natural cycle is for the mango trees to produce fruit for only 3 months a year, which doesn’t meet market demand.  They use PBZ, a chemical to block the growth hormone of leaves and instead allow flowers to grow.  Once the flowers grow the trees are sprayed with Ammonium Nitrate to stimulate the tree and encourage flowers (within 3 weeks) and then fruit growth (in 3 months).  Both PBZ and Ammonium Nitrate can pollute water supplies, whilst PBZ can carry health risks.  They have almost doubled the output of mangoes from this farm.    The UK is Brazil’s biggest market for Mangoes, and we demand them all year round.

 Use of precious resources such as Crude oil

Crude oil is required in many ways in agriculture, from the obvious use in farm machinery to the production of chemical fertilisers and pesticides.  Much of our agriculture is reliant on a non renewable resource, rendering it unsustainable in the long term.

 Damage to soils

Soils are impacted by having to absorb persistent chemical use and by over use.  We have witnessed a decline in Organic matter caused by intensive farming, drainage of carbon-rich soil (e.g. peat and wetlands), soil erosion and climate change.  Soils also have reduced biodiversity because of chemical use, and fertility falls because of reduced vegetation cover and being used to grow the same crop over and over again. 

 Damage to existing natural ecosystems

Many countries have extended the amount of land they farm by colonising new parts of their countries.  This is often to the cost of the natural environment and ecosystems.  Rich nations like the UK and France colonised lots of new land, France drained wetlands in the Vendee and Camargue for agriculture, and Brazil has found an ingenious way to farm in the Savannah of the Mato Grosso.  Here in Sapezal, in the interior, and much of the landscape is not great farmland.  It is Savannah, and used to cover ¼ of Brazil, it could not be farmed.  All of the plants were stunted because the soil is of poor quality and the savannah has adapted to this poor soil, unfertile for plants.  But scientists have created an agricultural area 1/3 the size of Europe here, that they think can expand in future.  Andre Magi built this farming dynasty, and the family own one of the largest farming businesses in the world.  This area is farmed commercially and one farm is cultivated using 50 huge combined harvesters (costing $20million from John Deere), they use economies of scale to harvest soy beans which go into 60% of processed foods and goes into animal feed.  Without it, millions would starve.  Brazil is second only to the USA for Soy production.  The region produced 18 million tonnes in one year, enough to feed half of Europe.  However, to do this they have reduced the acidity of the soil, which naturally has a pH of 4-5.  This acidic soil mixed with high levels of aluminium and released it to contaminate the water supply and poison the plants, reducing their ability to take up water and nutrients.  The Brazilians mixed lime into the soil to solve this problem and allow the farmers to grow plants in the Savannah.  They can harvest twice a year and seeding takes place straight after harvest.  Chemical fertilisers go into the soil, automatically with the seeds.  The downside is that these fields are monocultures, losing diverse habitat and increasing the use of chemicals. Brazil has also allowed development of the Southern Amazon Basin, Bom Jesus do Araguaia, Mato Grosso.  Here, cattle ranchers have transformed the Amazon, an area over 3 times the size of the UK has been destroyed in 30 years for cattle ranches.  There are over 70million cattle in the Amazon region, as Brazil strives to be the biggest exporter of beef in the world.  John Carter wants to farm cattle sustainably.  There are problems with lawlessness, squatters and illegal deforestation.  Landowners clear huge areas of forest for cattle ranching; this is because beef brings in good money

 

Ghost acres and monocultures

Ghost acres relate to those acres of land in poorer countries that are used for the production of export crops.  They are “ghost” acres because for an often undernourished population in an LEDC the land is unavailable to produce food for that local population.  The term ghost acres was coined in India about land used for goods to be exported to Britain).  The other major problem environmentally on many of these ghost acres is that the crops produced are monocultures.  These take the same nutrients time and again from the soil and also drastically reduce biodiversity (palm oil production replacing tropical forests is a good example here).

 Use of water

Intensive agriculture consumes huge amounts of water.  In the Punjab state they participated fully in the Green revolution and massively increased productivity for wheat.  However, to do so they have massively decreased the level of the water table and now face water shortages. The water table in Punjab is at 30 meters deep and even 80 meters in some areas; each year it loses over a metre (source).  Current forecasts paint a dismal picture of impending desertification because 60% of irrigated water is still pumped from the ground.

 Sustainable agriculture and sustainable food supplies

There are alternatives in the hunt for more sustainable agriculture, and perhaps we are ready for a revolution in the way we produce and consume food globally.  Sustainable agriculture relates to the ability of farmers to produce food indefinitely without causing damage to the local environment.  The concept of Sustainable food supplies are wider in definition, including sustainable agriculture but also considering the transport issue as well.  Pressure group Sustain says food should be produced, processed and traded in ways that:

  , and Contribute to thriving local economies and sustainable livelihoods at home and abroad

  Protect the diversity of plants and animals and avoid damaging natural resources and contributing to climate change

  Provide social benefits, such as good quality food, safe and healthy products and educational opportunities

 

Some ideas for improving sustainability include;

Organic

The Soil Association certifies 70% of the UK's £1.9bn organic food sector, and perhaps organic agriculture is the way forward to reducing chemical and crude oil use.    Commercial intensive farming involves practices where the purpose is to maximise yields.  This also maximises profits and increases food security, and makes more money for supermarket chains and food processing companies. Intensive farming needs a high investment of capital per unit area of land, this investment generally taking the form of machinery and chemicals, but sometimes including greenhouses and ventilation and irrigation systems.  It also does not favour local food supplies but large scale specialisation in large farm plots and then transfer to market.  Organic farming is a much more sustainable method, in that it reduces the intensification of food production and encourages a more local approach.  Artificial fertilisers are banned and farmers develop fertile soil by rotating crops and using compost, manure and clover. Strict regulations, known as ‘standards’, define what organic farmers can and cannot do – and place a strong emphasis on the protection of wildlife and the environment.  You can find out more from the Soil Association.

   

There are alternatives to pesticides.  Biological control is an alternative to using pesticides. By releasing a natural predator into the crop growing area, the number of pests can be reduced. However, this can have unforeseen consequences as the numbers of different organisms in the food web are changed. There have been examples of the predator becoming a more serious pest than the original problem.  An example of Biological control is the introduction of the small wasp, Trichogramma ostriniae, was introduced from China to help control the European corn borer making it a recent example of a long history of classical biological control efforts for this major pest.

Local food sourcing, eating seasonally and grow your own

There is a growing movement in the UK for people to eat seasonal vegetables and fruit wherever possible, in order to reduce the food miles.  Local food sourcing is also becoming more and more popular.  The red tractor logo appears on lots of food stuffs now to show that the food is produced in the United Kingdom.  Red Tractor Assurance exists to maintain, develop and promote standards throughout the whole food industry.  

Local food sourcing comes in other ways too.  Local food stores have pushed local food produce as a counter measure against the internationalism of the supermarkets.  Farmers markets have also become popular, where farmers from local areas get together to sell their produce direct to the consumer and cut out the retailers.  There is also direct marketing, where farmers get together to deliver food boxes to your door. 

 

Stewardship

Environmental Stewardship (ES) is an agri-environment scheme which offers payments to farmers and land managers in England for effective land management to protect and enhance the environment and wildlife. The scheme is delivered for Defra by Natural England and forms part of the Rural Development Programme for England (2007-2013). It builds on the successes of previous agri-environment schemes, the Countryside Stewardship Scheme and Environmentally Sensitive Areas.

The scheme’s primary objectives are to:

  • Conserve wildlife (biodiversity)
  • Maintain and enhance landscape quality and character
  • Protect the historic environment
  • Protect natural resources (water and soil)
  • Promote public access and understanding of the countryside

There are also secondary objectives for genetic conservation (rare breeds), flood risk management, and an overarching objective to contribute to climate change adaptation and mitigation. Nearly 6.5 million hectares (nearly 70% of England’s farmland) are in agri-environment schemes (43,000 Environmental Stewardship agreements covering 5.5 million hectares plus predecessor scheme agreements still in force covering approximately 700,000 hectares).  (Source).  At the entry level, farmers are paid £30 per hectare to show that they protect and manage the environment through effective management.   There are 50 options including hedgerow management, stone wall maintenance, ditch and pond management, management of archaeological sites, and creating buffer strips around fields to create new habitats, protect habitats from fertilisers and sprays spreading, stabilizing banks and protecting water courses from pollution.  

The use of biotechnology

Selecting and developing plants with tolerance to pests can reduce the use of pesticides.  A study found that where farmers plant biotech soy, corn, cotton or canola, pesticide use has fallen by 286 million kg, or 7.9 percent. The reductions come from herbicide-tolerant traits and insect-protection traits that reduce the number of pesticide applications required by farmers to grow their crops. (source).  You can read more on biotechnology here.

 Fair trade

Fair trade falls into the category of sustainability because it is concerned with improving the lives of people socially by guaranteeing a reasonable price for their produce.  The fair trade scheme also has elements of good practices towards the environment within it.  Co-operatives are also a way forward, and the UK Cooperative actually runs its own farms and has a scheme designed to help the honey bee whose numbers are struggling in the UK.  They are also encourage global cooperatives to help small farmers.

 Appropriate technology

Improving farming in poorer countries can reduce the need to import and there fore transport food.  The use of appropriate technology can achieve this and you can read more about this strategy here.

 

Find out more from the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations.