Back to main Back to Advanced level Back to Food Supply

Environmental aspects of the global trade in foodstuffs.

The potential for sustainable food supplies.

Globalisation of Food supply

"For people who want to buy corn, there really isn't much choice but to come to us.’"

Bob Kohlmeyer, former manager, Cargill corporation

 Changes to food supply and demand have resulted in a massive change in the way that we source our food and in our diets.  Indeed, many of the food stuffs that are consumed in the UK are produced elsewhere.  This includes;

  • foods that cannot be grown in the UK because of our temperate climate (e.g. bananas, pineapples, lemons),
  • foods that cannot be grown in sufficient quantity to meet demand (e.g. we can produce sugar in the UK using sugar beet but still have to import lots of sugar from tropical areas from sugar cane to meet demand),
  • foods that can be grown in other countries when they are not in season in the UK (e.g. apples in winter) and;
  • foods that can simply be produced cheaper elsewhere because the producer has a competitive advantage in some way (e.g. cheaper labour in LEDCs such as Kenya, economies of scale in places with large landmasses such as grain production in the Prairies of North America, specialisation in places such as Mangoes in Brazil).

The flow chart below reveals this process in terms of the Chicken industry, and even if the chickens are reared in the UK the example clearly shows that the chicks may be born elsewhere and imported and the product can end up in different countries (exported).

Source

This is the concept or phenomenon of the globalisation of food production and consumption, and it is not exclusive to the UK but reaches into the heart of every continent.  Principally, at the heart of the globalisation of food and consumption is the FREE MARKET ECONOMY that has evolved over time and consumer demand in MEDCs, plus the need for countries to gain export income from cash crops.  This is not a new idea, and trade in food stuffs has occurred for many centuries including the Spice trail of the 15th Century which brought pepper, vanilla and nutmeg to Europe, the triangular trade which involved moving industrial goods from Europe to West Africa, slaves from West Africa to the Americas and finally plantation goods such as tobacco and sugar back to Europe (16th to 19th centuries), and tea from India to the UK (through the East India Company) as notable examples.  Indeed, many things have fuelled and allowed the globalisation of food including;

  1. the ever increasing demand in MEDCs for non seasonal produce (e.g. Strawberries in Winter),
  2. consumer diets changing,
  3. the impact of migration widening diets and knowledge of global food types
  4. the availability of multimedia such as the Internet and television broadening peoples culinary horizons
  5. the increasing availability of exotic food stuffs
  6. the improvement in productivity in farming in LDCs and LEDCs
  7. improvements in transport technology and the expansion of trade routes
  8. huge advances in the preservatives industry
  9. the development of huge Trans National Corporations controlling the supply chain
  10. the demands and influence of major retailers in the UK – including the supermarkets

 The major players in Globalisation;

TNCs

Trans National Corporations are huge in food supply.  This can be seen on this page. Action Aid published a brilliant document that showed that TNCs are controlling an ever increasing share of production and wield ever greater power in the following ways;  

1) Seed and agrochemicals

• Six TNCs – BASF, Bayer, Dow, DuPont, Monsanto and Syngenta – now control 75-80% of the global pesticides market, down from 12 corporations in 1994.

• DuPont and Monsanto together dominate the world seed markets for maize (65%), and soya (44%).

• Monsanto controlled 91% of the global genetically modified (GM) seed market in 2001 and took over 60% of the Brazilian non-GM maize seed market in the space of two years (1997-1999).

• Bayer controls 22% of the Indian pesticide market.

 

2) Bulk commodity trading

• Two US TNCs, Chiquita and Dole Foods, control almost 50% of the world trade in bananas.

• Archer Daniels Midland (ADM), Barry Callebaut and Cargill dominate Côte d’Ivoire’s cocoa processing industry, where 95% of processing capacity is controlled by TNCs.

• Fyffes, the largest fresh produce distributor in Europe, is the sole exporter of bananas from Belize and Surinam.

• Three companies – ADM, Cargill and Zen Noh – handle over 80% of US corn exports.

 

3) Food manufacturing and processing

• The top ten food processing companies account for 37% of sales by the largest 100 companies in the industry.

• Three companies control 85% of the world’s tea market, and Unilever is the world’s biggest tea supplier.

• Nestlé has established a virtual monopoly of the UHT milk market in Pakistan, and controls around 80% of Peru’s milk production.

• Four companies, including Cargill and Tyson, control 81% of the US beef packing industry.

 

4) Food retailing

• The 30 largest food retailing corporations account for around one-third of all world grocery sales, with the top 10 amassing combined sales of US$649 billion in 2002.

• Wal-Mart controls 40% of Mexico’s retail sector.

• Thirty-six per cent of all food sales in Thailand are now channelled through TNC retailers, where Tesco had 48 outlets and sales of around US$1.2 billion in 2003.

• Asda Wal-Mart, Safeway, Sainsbury, and Tesco account for 75% of food sales in the UK.

Source: ActionAid “Power Hungry”

 The table below summarises how TNCs can dominate the food supply chain from start to finish, right from the production of seeds through to trade, onto processing and finally the sale of the product.  This leaves very little room for small holders and farmers!

 

WTO

The World Trade Organisation are a global organisation that are a major player in the globalisation of food.  They exist to try and regulate and control trade, and in this instance that trade is in food stuffs. The origins of our current system are found in the Bretton Woods agreement, which sought to reorganise the world post World War 2. This agreement created the World Bank and International Monetary Fund (IMF) both based in New York. These 2 organisations lend money to countries in trouble (as they were across Europe post WW2) but also advise countries on domestic and trade matters. In addition, the General Agreement of Tariffs and Trade (GATT) was also instigated to control world trade, to ensure fairness and to help legally secure trade. This was superseded by the World Trade Organisation in 1995 - which aims to liberalise (or free up) trade, negotiate trade agreements and settle trade disputes. The Doha round of WTO talks sought to reduce the tariffs on imported goods in an attempt to help poorer nations.  However, many MEDCs have benefitted massively from free trade, whilst many LEDCs have suffered a fall in prices for their primary products.

 

Trading blocs

The other big political bodies involved include the G8 and G20 groups of most powerful economies. The heads of state from these countries meet regularly and also have a huge impact upon the trade of agricultural goods. It is often argued that these countries exert far too much influence over the IMF and World Bank, and on the WTO. It is also argued that they bias the world trade system in their favour. In the past their have been anti-capitalist protests and even riots aimed at the WTO, the IMF and the G8/G20.  Trading blocs such as the European Union can promote global trade too, by actively encourageing production in LEDCs through aid.  This has alos been the case through charitable organisations, such as the Rockefeller foundation and the Ford foundation.  They established the Rice Research Institute, which led to the green revolution in LEDCs and promoted commercial agriculture and hence globalisation above local produce and subsistence farming.

 

Technology

Technology in food production has advanced incredibly.  Transport has become more widely available including the use of planes, boats and lorries, whilst preservation methods have increased too.  Preservation of food basically means to try to stop the growth of yeasts, fungi, bacteria and micro organisms. Traditional measures such as drying food and salting have been joined by a staggering number of ways to preserve food from freezing, to vacuum packing, to irradiation and using modified atmospheres.  These have all allowed food to be kept for longer and to travel longer distances, thus increasing the globalisation of food production.

 

Impacts and issues

There are several issues that arise from the globalisation of food production;

  1. Farmers are getting less and less of an income - In the 1950s, of every £1 spent on food and drink 50-60% went to the farmer. Today, just 9% of every £1 spent on food and drink goes back to the farmers
  2. Supermarkets dominate the retail of food in the UK – the major supermarkets dominate slaes. Tesco, Asda, Morrisons and Sainsburys dominate over 75% of the UK’s grocery sales

 

  1. Food and drink is the largest manufacturing industry in  the UK at 14% of manufacturing output
  2. Food distribution accounts for 40% of all freight transport in the UK
  3. Animals are travelling ever greater distances, making disease out breaks such as foot and mouth (2007) ever more likely
  4. Lack of competition allows TNCs to drive down prices.
  5. LEDCs have opened up their markets whilst many MEDCs including the EU used protectionism to protect their farmers
  6. Farming has intensified in most countries, leading to the increased use of chemicals which raise production but which damage the environment
  7. Large tracts of rainforest including in Brazil have been demolished to make way for farming areas
  8. Migrant and seasonal workers have work, but the conditions are poor
  9. Food is travelling further, increasing carbon footprints and food miles
  10. There is pressure on countries to produce biofuel, but should we produce food or fuel on our land?
  11. Ghost acres – these are acres of land given over to export crops, often in countries where there are food shortages, are these acres ethical?
  12. Cleaning up the chemical pollution, repairing the habitats and coping with sickness caused by industrial farming costs up to £2.3 billion a year
  13. Animals are reared on production lines with poor animal welfare standards
16.Water is effectively exported with exported food