Back to Main Back to A - level Back to Globalisation
‘Sustainable tourism, myth or reality’.

Sustainable tourism, myth or reality?

The idea of sustainable tourism was proposed at the first Earth Summit held in Rio in 1992. In the following Agenda 21 process, travel and tourism was one of the industries identified as having the potential to make a positive contribution to a healthier planet.

Sustainable tourism can be defined as “Tourism that takes full account of its current and future economic, social and environmental impacts, addressing the needs of visitors, the industry, the environment and host communities” (UNWTO, 2004).

The roots of sustainability come from the idea of sustainable development introduced by the Bruntland Commission in the 1970s and stated that "sustainable development is development that meets the needs of present generations without compromising the needs of future generations to meet their own needs."

Sustainable tourism should;

·        Support a wide range of local economic activities, taking environmental costs and benefits into account.

·        Should not be permitted to become an activity which dominates the economic base of an area (other industries should exist alongside).

·        Allow the participation of local communities

·        Involve indigenous people, women and minority groups to ensure the equitable distribution of the benefits of tourism.

·        Respect the culture, the economy and the way of life, the environment and political structures in the destination area.

·        Educate all involved people (stakeholders) about the need to develop more sustainable forms of tourism.

Questions to consider about “Sustainable tourism: myth or reality?”;

1.      Can Tourism ever really be sustainable? 

2.      Can people “leave only footsteps and take only memories”?

3.      How do we attract and service the greatest number of tourists without causing irreparable change or damage to the destination’s resources?

4.      Is the idea of sustainable tourism one that can truly be achieved in a practical, profit driven world?

5.      Is sustainable tourism a myth or a reality?

6.      Does the level of development of a place affect the possibility of sustainable tourism?

The Myths

1.      Tourism is a huge source of income for many countries who will sacrifice environmental concerns in order to boost GDP and attract overseas income. This means that many areas will exceed their “carrying capacity”, the ability of the environment to absorb the impact of the tourism.

2.      INTERNATIONAL Mass tourism is the most popular form of tourism as it is the most practical and cheapest form.  It is also the most damaging for the environment and least sustainable.

3.      The increase of international tourism is hugely unsustainable.  This results in very damaging forms of transport being used such as the aeroplane. According to the World Tourist Organisation 1.1billion people arrived as international tourists in 2014 and generated US$1.5trillion in export earnings.

4.      Tourism can be considered to be ECONOMICALLY unsustainable, as tourist resorts can follow the Butler life cycle model and end up in a decline situation.  This has been the case in Blackpool which has had to work very hard to combat this.

5.      Tourism can have many negative impacts SOCIALLY, from the increase in drug use and prostitution to cultural dilution and pollution.

6.      Extreme tourism is on the increase which places pressure on FRAGILE environments that have less capacity to cope. Again tourism having a negative impact

7.      LEDCs have less capacity to cope with the impacts of tourism than MEDCs

Realities

1.      Sustainable tourism offers poor countries a way out of poverty and an opportunity to protect their natural environment.

2.      Sustainable tourism offers an alternative to the highly damaging effects of mass tourism

3.      Richer countries have developed over time a tourism that can be sustainable both economically and socially although problems remain.  The Lake District National Park is a good example of this.

4.      Sustainable tourism offers people a way of using their cultural and social skills in a positive way within their local environment.

5.      Tourism is a labour intensive industry that creates millions of jobs worldwide, attracts significant foreign income and investment, and is one of the most promising drivers of green growth for the world economy.

6.      Local tourism and “Stay-cationing” can limit the damaging impacts of international tourism.

7.      Sustainable tourism has meant that people are more educated today than two decades ago about the impacts of tourism.

8.      Money generated from tourism is being re invested into protecting the environment and ensuring local culture is not lost.

 

CASE STUDIES

There is some decent case study material found at the following GCSE links;

Sustainable management of mass tourism in the Lake District National Park

Attempts at sustainable management of mass tourism in the tropics – Jamaica

Sustainable management of the Galapagos Islands

Problems and management in Extreme Environments - Antarctica

Unsustainable Tourism;

The case of Ibiza

Ibiza is a major holiday destination in the Balearic Islands directly south of Barcelona and South West of Mallorca in the Mediterranean Sea.  It has 210 kilometres of shoreline and 53 beaches. In the 2001 census, the Island had a resident population of 88,000 people, by 2010 that had grown to 133,000. This Mediterranean Island is under unsustainable pressure from mass tourism as 6,000,000 tourists flock to the popular island each summer. The island not only has a classic Mediterranean climate but also a legendary and at times riotous nightlife in Ibiza Town, the island's capital on the southern shore and Sant Antoni to the West. In the last decades Ibiza and Formentera tourism industries have undergone explosive growth; this massive flow of tourists in a short period of time exceeds the capacity of the islands’ environment, and has generated a huge demand for land, water and energy, while producing an increasing volume of wastes.

In 2007 a panel of more than 500 tourist experts rated Ibiza worst out of 111 islands around the world in terms of tourism impact.

According to Ibizaconservationfund.org the current issues of concern relating to tourism include:

  1. Transformed coastlines and inland landscapes – as tourist resorts spring up around the coast and spread inland, destroying natural habitat.
  2. Large transport infrastructure – plans exist to expand the airport to over 1 million passengers a year and a macro port has been built that UNESCO say has posed an unacceptable threat to Posidonia meadows declared World Heritage site
  3. Loss of important habitats and biodiversity – many are under threat due to increasing mass tourism, including the Balearic Shearwater bird and marine habitats such as the Ses Salines prairies
  4. Water scarcity and pollution - water demand from mass tourism has led to depleted and polluted aquifers and to a growing dependency on desalination plants
  5. Increased pollution due to soaring energy use –energy use has gone up 70% in the last decade
  6. Increased waste – in the summer most sewage is dumped in the sea as plants cannot cope with the volumes
  7. Loss of rural landscapes, agrobiodiversity and traditional knowledge on sustainable resource management – people have abandoned farming in favour of tourism based activities
  8. Loss of cultural heritage - Dalt Vila, declared cultural UNESCO World Heritage site in 1999, abounds in beautiful – and derelict – buildings. Archaeological sites, largely ignored, are being destroyed by road-building and urban development.

The Island is also under threat from oil drilling in the Mediterranean Sea and Forest fires.

 

Peru and Sustainable Tourism

Ecotourism is a very important part of the tourism industry in Peru. In the East you can take part in Eco-tourism activities in the Amazon Basin, as found along the Madre De Dios River near to Puerto Maldonado.  Peru has some fantastic coastline as well, but the highlight of Peru is undoubtedly the Inca Trail. Peru’s considerable natural resources and historical attractions make it critical that sustainable tourism is a focus of the industry. Ecotourism in Peru is a diverse segment of the industry, and includes conservation and preservation efforts of historical landmarks, nature, and communities, through economic and socio-cultural initiatives and dedicated tour operators. Birdwatching is a treat in Peru, particularly because of the mighty condor, an iconic and mammoth bird often spotted in the Colca Canyon. Similarly, orchid lovers will thoroughly enjoy Peru and its approximately 3,000 species of orchids, scattered in places like Callejon de Huaylas valley, and Machu Picchu. Research estimates put the number of butterfly species in Peru at 4,200.

Machu Picchu, Peru ©Rob Gamesby

In 1911 American explorer Hiram Bingham was led to the former Inca settlement and tourists have been visiting ever since. You can take a virtual field trip of the Inca Trail here.  The trail basically covers 43km of old pathways linking together old Inca settlements in the inhospitable mountains of the Andes.  It is South America's best known trek and is one of only 23 World Heritage Sites (as deemed by UNESCO) to be classified as important both naturally and culturally.  The rail is covered in 4 days and finishes with sunrise at the "Lost City of the Incas" at Machu Picchu.  The trail is strictly controlled, and only 500 trekkers are allowed to start out on the trail every day.

Cusco, most Inca trail Trekkers leave from here ©Rob Gamesby

Additionally, Machu Picchu is home to a number of Peru's exceptional natural species, all of which require their natural environment to be considerate and undisturbed.

During a trek along the Inca Trail, the following is absolutely prohibited:

·        Littering

·        Lighting campfires and cooking over an open flame

·        Spending the night in archaeological sites

·        Gathering plants, flowers, insects, and animals along the route

In addition;

·        The Inca Trail is closed for the rainy month of February.

·        Regulations limit the Trail to 500 trekkers a day, including tour guides, porters, and cooks.

·        Trek permits are needed to walk the trail to protect it

·        There are strict regulations on behaviour on the Inca Trail as well as in Machu Picchu, commanding respect and awareness of the fragility of the site due to human visitation.

·        Tourists are advised how much to pack in order to limit the weight local porters have to carry

·        Local guides provide an educational element to the trip

Many of the guides and porters are from local communities and they supplement their farm income during the trekking season, this vital income supports their families.

Local Peruvian guides on the Inca Trail ©Rob Gamesby

There is also ecotourism in the Peruvian Amazon.  I stayed in ecotourism lodge in Puerto Maldonado in Peru, where tours of the Amazon forest take place for tourists staying in small wooden huts there is limited electricity and waste is dealt with on site, and the food at the resort is sourced locally.  All of the guides were local and the tours were educational.

Ecotourism lodge in the Peruvian Amazon ©Rob Gamesby