Back to Main Back to A - level Back to Globalisation
‘Trade versus aid’.

This is a central development topic and one that provokes conflict and argument.  There are huge disparities or inequalities between people WITHIN countries and between people along the development continuum from those living in LDCs to those in MEDCs.  Not only are there differences in their standard of living (an ECONOMIC MEASURE) but these income differences often result in huge differences in people’s quality of life (a Qualitative non-economic measure).

The CENTRAL CORE ISSUE here with this topic is how we try to reduce these inequalities so that the poor are not so poor.  Do we promote the values of TRADE, and in particular, globalised free trade, or do we try to assist the poorest nations in the world through AID? 

The examiner will expect you to explore both and include case studies of places to support your arguments, and then come to a view.

THE BASICS – WHAT IS TRADE?

Trade is the exchange of goods, money and services between countries and regions. The goods made in a region and sold to other places and known as Exports (they Exit the country or region). The goods bought into a place from other regions are known as Imports (they come Into the country or region).

If value of exports for a country or region is greater than its imports it will have a trade surplus. If a region imports more than it sells then it will have a trade deficit.

Most MEDCs and NICs import primary products which have low value and export high value manufactured goods an even higher value services.

Most LEDCs export lower value primary products (such as cocoa, cotton etc.), this means that they struggle to raise standards of living in their countries because they do not have much foreign money coming in from trade. The price of primary goods also varies widely and producers can lose out massively, so the trade in a sense is unfair. 

Fair Trade

This is a scheme designed to get a better deal for the producers of the primary products that MEDC countries need. The producers get access to the market for their goods, a contract (for extra financial security), better prices for their products and access to the Fair Trade Premium, which is a sum of money available from the Fair Trade foundation to be spent upon improving yields, farming practices, health care or education. Fair Trade is an international movement and its influence is growing, more than 4,500 products now bear the fair trade mark, and 72% of the UK population recognise the Fair Trade logo.  In addition, more than 7 million people in Africa, Asia and Latin America benefit from Fair Trade - farmers, farm workers, and their families.

THE BASICS – WHAT IS AID?

Aid is basically a form of help given from one country to another; or one person to another, or from a charity (often called Non-Government Organisations or NGOs) to a country or region. It is most likely that you will have given aid at some point in your life! Aid can be given in the short term for emergencies, like during the 2004 Boxing Day Tsunami, when money poured into South East Asia to help the victims and the sick. Development aid is longer term, and seeks to help people in poorer countries raise their standard of living. Below is a table summarising the different types of aid;

Type of aid

What it is

Image

Medical assistance

During emergencies rich nations and charities like the Red Cross or Medecin sans frontiers can provide medical assistance to the affected country. This could take the form of qualified staff or medicines.


Emergency aid in Haiti and Kenya

People

Richer nations or charities might choose to send qualified people top help in poorer nations. In the short term during emergencies qualified medical staff and trained pilots and the army can be of great assistance. In the longer term teachers, engineers, consultants can all play a role in advising and train in people within a poorer nation, to help its long term development.

Money

Money is often sent to LEDCs, for investment in projects and the local people. The UK sent £45million in aid to Tanzania to be spent on education.

Large scale projects

MEDCs can invest in large scale development projects, such as building roads, dams and factories. The idea behind these projects is that they act as a growth point for development, allowing industry and farming to develop and raise massive profits.



Intermediate technology

This type of technology is designed to improve on current technology within LEDC countries and to be manageable for local people to use. There is no point in sending machinery and technology into an area if the people can get no use of it because it is too complicated.

Equipment

Large scale equipment can also be provided in aid to LEDCs. Equipment such as tractors, irrigation equipment and earth movers have all been provided in the past.

Aid can also be tied or untied. Tied aid is when the country giving the aid expects something in return for the aid - the host country may have to trade more with the donor country for example. Untied aid is where the receiving country does not have to give anything in return.

 

Debt relief as aid

Many LEDCs took out huge loans (for Millions of pounds) during the 1970s, offered to them by banks and governments in rich MEDCs. The LEDCs wanted to use the money for various development projects such as building dams, roads, schools etc. The idea was to help countries to develop by improving their industries and infrastructure.  The loans had to be paid back, and the longer the loan went unpaid the larger it got, because the MEDCs added a sum of money called interest every month. Over time these loans got so large because of interest that some LEDCs would never be able to pay them off. It also meant that some MEDCs spent more on loan payments than on health care and education for the people living in their countries. This has had a really damaging effect on the quality of life of people who live in these areas.

Countries can borrow money from many sources, including other countries, banks and international organisations such as the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and World Bank.  If a project succeeds debts are easily repaid and there is no issue.  However, if a project fails debts can build up because of the interest and countries can get into huge financial trouble.  This issue can massively affect the development of a country, which directly affects the standard of living of the people who live there.

In the run up the new millennium a campaign was started to drop the debt, which has had some success in cancelling some debt, freezing the interest on some debt and in some cases giving the poorer LEDCs more time to pay back their debts. This campaign was called Jubilee 2000. As a result of this campaign the UK government cancelled much but not all of the debts owed to it by poorer nations.  Banks have not cancelled debts however, and many countries the world over suffer the effects of debt. 39 developing countries are eligible for special assistance from the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the World Bank.

CONSERVATION SWAPS AS AID

This is another way for poorer countries to make money and get themselves out of debt.  Many poorer countries have abundant natural resources and these can be used or exploited in many ways.  The rain forests are a good example; these are exploited in an unsustainable manner for wood, agriculture and mineral wealth.  Conservation swaps offer an alternative to poorer countries to reckless exploitation of their natural wealth.  These swaps basically see poorer countries have portions of their debts wiped out or paid for by richer nations or charities of richer nations in exchange for promising to protect or CONSERVE large parts of their natural environment.  This has large scale global effects, by protecting the atmosphere and the hydrosphere. 

CASE STUDY - In 1984 the World Wildlife Fund came up with the idea of conservation swaps and in 1987 the first was launched in partnership between the Government of Bolivia and Conservation International (CI) for US$ 650000 which protected 3 natural areas. Many countries have since followed, including the Philippines, Sudan, Zambia, Ecuador and Uganda.

Arguments For and Against Trade and Aid

Aid positives

Aid negatives

Trade positives

Trade Negatives

Aid is often FOCUSSED on target groups and problems – often the poorest people in society and improving their lives. On the other hand, trade is less efficient as it is profit driven and the benefit of trade is mostly confined within elite group of people of the country.

Countries can become dependent upon aid – this limits their willingness to follow their own sustainable development

International cooperation is promoted in the long term Poorer less developed nations want to cooperate with richer nations for trade advantages. This will allow a flow of money and goods into the country.

Open free trade can be very risky to vulnerable economies.  Poorer nations have very fragile economies dealing with small numbers of products with high price variability. 

 

Aid can be given in many different ways so is flexible.  Emergency short term aid can be given, and aid doesn’t even need to be economic, it could be through the use of advice and experts.

Aid budgets can be cut – if the donor country has tougher economic times they might cut the aid budget.  Similarly, if the donor country does not like current governments or policies in poorer countries they may pull the aid money.

The promotion of trade can have POSITIVE multiplier effects.  Once an industry or resource or industry is established and trading globally, other companies can provide services or components to that industry boosting the economy further.  The employment created generates tax income for the government and people have wages to spend in the local economy.

Trade requires investment first. Many poor countries do not have the money to invest in making their industries efficient so that they can compete with richer nations and companies.

 

Aid can actually help people, both in times of crisis and over the long term.  This fulfils people’s moral obligations and engenders global good will.

Aid can be unsustainable and inappropriate. This has particularly been the case with big aid projects and tied aid projects.  See the Cahora Bassa scheme on this website. Aid money has also been known to “disappear” in corrupt countries, before it does any benefit for the people who live there.

Trade can boost employment. 

Free trade as desired by the WTO doesn’t really exist due to protectionism and trading blocs.  Areas like the EU protect their industries behind trade barriers like Import tariffs whilst subsidizing their own industries.  This damages poorer nation’s ability to trade.

Aid can stimulate trade, which may continue into the future after the initial stimulus.  It can also create jobs for people from wealthy nations and people in the recipient country.

 

Aid is difficult to coordinate and manage – this is because there are many sources of aid such as countries, charities and international organisation such as the UN.  Each of these donors may have their own AGENDA.

TNCs can bring with them technology and training when they trade in nations.  These are transferrable, so boost the overall skill and technology level of the poorer nation.

Trade can be viewed as a form of NEOCOLONIALISM. Many richer nations and their TNCs are accused of using the natural resources and people of poorer nations to their own advantage, a new form of ECONOMIC colonialism.

Aid can be very sustainable at the local level and from the bottom up.  Appropriate technology and sustainable development projects can have huge impacts on the standard of living of people at the local scale.

Aid can be viewed negatively as a hand out and as a form of charity; where the developing countries need to admit the superiority of the developed country.

Trade helps developing countries to maintain their dignity, allowing them to work their way out of poverty (“give a man a fish and feed him for a day, teach him how to fish and feed him for life”)

Trade can encourage a “race to the Bottom”, as companies seek the lowest cost producers of goods normally at the detriment of the natural environment and the conditions of employment.

 You can see more on the pros and cons of aid here.

CASE STUDIES YOU CAN USE;

Trade;

1.      NICs – use China, Malaysia and India as ways that poorer nations can move towards higher levels of economic development through trade

2.      Shell – the impact of a TNC on trade, with particular reference to globalisation.

3.      DR of the Congo – the impact of trade on an LDC

4.      The EU – the way in which a trading Bloc can impact upon the world trade system

Aid

Cahora Bassa – Aid to an LDC

 

LARGE SCALE AID – the Cahora Bassa scheme in Mozambique

Development FACTFILE

 

Mozambique

South Africa

UK

GDP (PPP)

$26.22billion

$578.6 billion

$2,323 billion

HDI

0.327

0.629

0.875

Birth rate

39/1000

19/1000

12/1000

Infant mortality

74.6

42

4.5

Life expectancy

52.3

49.43

80.29

Population below the poverty line

52%

31.3%

14%

External debt

$4.88billion

$47.56 billion

$9.836 TRILLION

Electricity production

14.84 billion kWh

257.9 billion kWh

352.7 billion kWh

Electricity exports

8.53 billion kWh

15.04 billion kWh

4.481 billion kWh

Electricity from HEP

99.9%

1.5%

1.9%

Source – CIA Fact book 2013

Dams are often seen by countries as a great way of raising the development level of a country.  They offer energy for other industries, the energy they produce is environmentally “clean” and the construction of such large structures generates instant employment in construction and its associated industries.

Mozambique, one of the poorest countries in the world, attempted to use dam building as a path out of poverty through the construction of the Cahora Bassa Dam. This is a good example of bilateral aid, as although Mozambique now has full ownership of the dam, initially Portugal had an 82% stake and Mozambique only 18%.  Mozambique also had to contract much of the work to private companies, diminishing their share of profits further.  As can be seen in the table, Mozambique desperately needs a boost to its development, with low HDI, high infant mortality and low life expectancy. 

The dam blocks the 4th largest artificial lake in Africa, and is one of 3 major dams along the mighty Zambezi River which passes through Congo, Angola, Zimbabwe and finally Mozambique.  It has created a lake that is 292km long, up to 32km wide and a maximum of 157m deep.

Image © Rob Gamesby

History

The dam was started in the 1960s by the then ruling Portuguese colonial government, in agreement with South Africa that a High Voltage Direct Current (HVDC) Transmission System would be put into place to move some of the power to South Africa.  The lake began to fill in 1974 but unfortunately a long civil war (post-independence from Portugal) prevented use of the scheme.  It was the transmission lines and towers that were damage limiting use of the electricity that Cahora Bassa could produce.  Finally, in 1995 renewal work began and by 1997 the dam was back in full operation but not at full capacity.

 

Pros and cons

The dam provides an important power import facility to the South African grid. It transmits 1920 MW of power from the Cahora Bassa generating station on the Zambezi River in northern Mozambique. One megawatt can power a thousand US homes on average, so the dam is very good at producing electricity. However, only 1% of homes in RURAL Mozambique have a direct electricity supply, so locals have not benefitted from the energy produced by the dam. This is because most of the power is sold to South Africa, which boosts the national economy but does not benefit citizens at a local level.  This is unfortunate, as the dam has enough potential to meet most of Mozambique’s power needs.

The dam could produce more energy, but its potential is limited by other dams upstream that keep river flows very low. At other economic levels, whilst the local shrimp industry has been destroyed a Kapenta fishery industry has developed, harvesting 10,000 tonnes in 2003. The potential for the dam to reduce flooding has also been a disappointment, with floods downstream of the dam in 1978.  Mozambique has also had floods on other rivers in 2000 and in January 2013 (which killed 36 and displaced 70,000 people - BBC).  These floods are an environmental limit to development, which the dams such as Cahora Bassa were hoped to reduce.

AID CASE STUDY 2 – APPROPRIATE TECHNOLOGY - Kenya

You could use ATA Asia case study here from Food supply

Intermediate or appropriate technology is a move away from big aid projects. It aims to use simpler technologies that are right for the people, right for the environment and right for the donor. In most poor countries, high tech industries are too expensive to develop and inappropriate to the needs of local people. Appropriate/intermediate technology is usually;

A) Labour intensive - utilising and creating employment for local labour.

B) Using sustainable technology and tools/knowledge of local people

C) Uses newly developed technology that are low cost and local which local people can manage and control rather than IMPORTED techniques and technologies

D) In harmony with the local environment.

Practical Action is a charity who uses appropriate technology in a number of ways. It has over 100 projects worldwide helping over 900,000 people. One type of project is using micro hydro-electric power stations to generate electricity so people can work their way out of poverty. Micro-hydro power is the small-scale gathering of energy from falling water, such as steep mountain rivers. Using this renewable, indigenous, non-polluting resource, micro-hydro plants can generate power for homes, hospitals, schools and workshops.

In Kenya Practical Action promotes small-scale hydro schemes that generate up to 500 kilowatts of power. This provides poor communities in rural areas with an affordable, easy to maintain and long-term solution to their energy needs. This means that this is a great example of Appropriate Technology. They have also developed micro-hydro systems with communities in Peru, Zimbabwe, and Sri Lanka. These systems, which are designed to operate for a minimum of 20 years, are usually 'run-of-the-river' systems.

Kenya –

The Intermediate Technology Development Group (ITDG) is a British Charity which has worked in Rural Kenya. It aims to help people meet their basic needs of food, clothing, housing, energy and employment. It uses local knowledge, training and finance to help people become more self-sufficient. In Kenya the ITDG has used soil as a local building source - as it can be compressed and it absorbs heat well. It can be stabilised against erosion using lime and natural fibres. Soil bricks stabilised with concrete are replacing more expensive industrially produced bricks.

The previously Nomadic Maasai herdsmen are being forced to become sedentary. ITDG is helping them find affordable housing, helping them repair roofs with small amounts of cement, and by incorporating guttering and water collection jars into housing women are being spared the job of walking long distance to collect water.

Kenyan women rely on wood for cooking. This can take rural women a long time to collect. An improved cooking stove (jiko) has been developed that reduces the amount of wood and charcoal needed and is based on a traditional design and constructed using scrap materials.