Back to Main Back to A - level Back to Globalisation

Reasons for, and consequences of the social and economic groupings of nations

 

CAUSES and REASONS

Many countries group together for different reasons;

1.      TRADE - There are several trading blocs, such as the NAFTA (North American Free Trade Association), the African Union (AU), OPEC and the European Union

2.      GLOBAL GOVERNANCE (economic)– such as other ECONOMIC groupings include the World Bank (An international organisation dedicated to providing financing, advice and research to developing nations to aid their economic development), IMF (International Monetary Fund who…) and the World Trade Organisation (WTO) who try to organise and make trade free.

3.      GLOBAL GOVERNANCE (SOCIAL) - There are global organisations of countries too, including the United Nations who have a huge role to play in organising the countries of the world to combat environmental issues such as Global Warming, tackle poverty through the UNDP, and ensure safety of people in conflicts through the use of the UN’s peace keeping force

4.      DEFENCE – There are defence groupings such as NATO (North Atlantic Treaty Organisation)

5.      SOCIAL, POLITICAL and ECONOMIC unions – the European Union is a great example of this, where various aspects of politics, law, society and the economy of member states are governed by the group of nations.

CHARACTERISTICS

A trading bloc is defined by four characteristics:

1.      There is a special trade relationship that promotes and allows trade within that group of countries in preference to trade with outside nations by discriminating against non-members (through import tariffs for example)

2.      It has the goal of trade  liberalisation or integration with the aim of establishing a free trade area, customs union, or common market

3.      It strives to reach common positions in negotiations with third countries, with other trade blocs, or in multilateral forums

4.      It attempts to coordinate national economic policies to minimize  disruption to intra-bloc economic transaction

(source)

Key words

Free Trade Areas - A free trade area is a grouping of countries within which tariffs and non-tariff trade barriers between the members are generally abolished but with no common trade policy toward non-members. The North American Free Trade Area (NAFTA) and the European Free Trade Association (EFTA) are examples of free trade areas.

Customs Unions - a group of states that have agreed to charge the same import duties as each other and usually to allow free trade between themselves.

Common Markets - a group of countries imposing few or no duties on trade with one another and a common tariff on trade with other countries (this last bit is the difference between a custom union and a common market).

Economic Unions - An economic union is a type of trade bloc which is composed of a common market with a customs union. The participant countries have both common policies on product regulation, freedom of movement of goods, services and the factors of production (capital and labour) and a common external trade policy.

NAFTA – the North American Free Trade Agreement – came into place in 1994 to ensure free trade between the USA, Canada and Mexico. Over the first 20 years of its existed it resulted in a 400% increase in trade between member states, included developed and developing countries and created a market of 460million consumers. (Source)

EU – the European Union

EEC – European Economic Community created by the Treaty of Rome in 1957, renamed as the European Community in 1993

GATT – the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade, which was signed in 1948 with the aim of reducing tariffs or import duties between countries and to have a forum for discussing the problems of international trade.  It was replaced in 1995 by the WTO or World Trade Organisation

WTO – the World Trade Organisation

BRIC – Brazil, Russia, India and China – a group of 4 countries identified by Jim O’Neil from Goldman Sacs as upcoming major global economic powers in 2001.

MINT – Mexico, Indonesia, Nigeria and Turkey - the next batch of potential economic giants identified again by Jim O’Neil in 2014.

G8 – The “Group of 8” most powerful countries in the world, which includes France, United States, United Kingdom, Russia, Germany, Japan, Italy, and Canada. Russia was suspended in 2014. It is a government panel which in 2012 controlled 40.9% of global GDP (PPP) in 2011 (source)

G20 - The Group of Twenty (also known as the G-20 or G20) is an international forum for the governments and central bank governors from 20 major economies. The members, shown highlighted on the map at right, include 19 individual countries—Argentina, Australia, Brazil, Canada, China, France, Germany, India, Indonesia, Italy, Japan, Mexico, Russia, Saudi Arabia, South Africa, South Korea, Turkey, the United Kingdom and the United States—along with the European Union (EU). The EU is represented by the European Commission and by the European Central Bank.

G77 - Group of 77 (G-77) was established on 15 June 1964 by seventy-seven developing countries signatories of the “Joint Declaration of the Seventy-Seven Developing Countries” issued at the end of the first session of the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) in Geneva.  The G77 aim to promote their collective economic interests and enhance their joint negotiating capacity on all major international economic issues (within the United Nations system).

World Bank - created at the end of World War II, because many European and Asian countries needed financing to fund reconstruction efforts. It was created at the Bretton Woods agreement of 1944. Today, it is an international organisation that attempts to fight poverty by offering developmental assistance to middle and poor-income countries. By giving loans, and offering advice and training in both the private and public sectors, the World Bank aims to eliminate poverty by helping people help themselves (World Bank website)

IMF - an organization of 188 countries, working to foster global monetary cooperation, secure financial stability, facilitate international trade, promote high employment and sustainable economic growth, and reduce poverty around the world.

The positive and negative CONSEQUENCES of the groupings of nations

 

Positives

Negatives

Socially

Within social and political unions people are often free to live and work in the country of their choice within the union.  This is the case within the EU. This means workers have more CHOICE.

Living standards go up as trade prospers

With relaxed borders it is easier for illegal immigrants to move around within the Bloc, this creates political issues too.

Legislation can limit workers as well as protect them – e.g. people might want to work more hours than stipulated in the Working Time Directive

Economically

(source of some of these)

Trade blocs protect the area’s economy from competition

Free trade within the bloc – Countries know that they have free access to each other's markets, so they can specialise. This means that, at the regional level, there is a wider application of the principle of comparative advantage.

Market access and trade creation – trade is likely to increase as countries have access to each other’s markets. These imports often have a lower cost because of specialization, so there is an increase in consumption, with increased demand resulting from lower prices.

Economies of scale – goods can be produced cheaper as countries can club together and benefit from economies of scale (buying in bulk, mass production etc.)

Jobs may be created as a consequence of increased trade between member economies. 3 million jobs are said to be directly related to the EU in 2011.

Firms inside the bloc are protected from cheaper imports from outside, such as the protection of the EU shoe industry from cheap imports from China and Vietnam. This is important for WEAKER sections of the economy.

Weaker disadvantaged peripheral regions can be supported by the stronger areas, as they are in Europe

The benefits of global free trade can be lost as countries concentrate trade within their trade area or bloc.

Inefficient producers within the bloc can be protected from more efficient ones outside the bloc. For example, inefficient European farmers may be protected from low-cost imports from developing countries because of the advantages of the CAP system of support for EU farmers

Trade wars – Trade blocs can lead to trade disputes where trading blocs argue with one another.  A classic example was between the EU and NAFTA, including the recent Boeing (US)/Airbus (EU) dispute. There were also the beef wars, where the EU banned USA reared beef that was raised with hormones and the US responded with £60million in tariffs on EU beef (see this BBC article).

Nonmember countries of the trade bloc will be ostracised (frozen out) since trade blocs are created to help only their member countries reduce trade barriers.

Trade blocs cost money – the EU will cost £960 BILLION from 2014 to 2020. (source) This money comes from taxing people in the member states, who may object to this.

 

Loss of some financial controls to a central authority such as a bank, e.g. European Central Bank

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-20442880

Environmentally

Social and economic unions can set high environmental standards – such as the EU’s regulations on waste, carbon emissions and even light bulbs.

Trading blocs increase food miles as the cheapest product within the bloc will be the most traded.  I bought “Scottish” smoked salmon that was raised in Scotland, processed in Poland and then shipped back to the UK for sale to me, 60 miles from the Scottish border!

Having to share resources may damage economic sectors, e.g. UK sharing traditional fishing grounds and fishing quotas

Politically

The incentives of trade and political cooperation help to reduce the chances of violent conflict; the EU owes its existence in part to this.

 

Giving individual countries greater political influence when dealing with other nations – the EU has lots of voting power in other institutions for example.

The benefits of democracy can be reinforced by the Bloc – the EU has its own parliament and everyone with the right to vote can vote.

Many of the groups are seen to be non-democratic.  For example, the IMF and World Bank both operate according to a complex voting structure that is loosely connected with economic power. That’s why the U.S., still by far the world’s largest economy in market GDP, has the largest share of votes: about 15 percent in the bank and 17 percent in the fund. Compared with their share of global population, rich countries as a whole are considerably overrepresented. (Source)

Trading blocs add another layer of government which costs money and add complications for countries making their own decisions.  The European High Court can overrule decisions made in British courts for example.

Loss of sovereignty with centralised decisions

Some smaller regions don’t like big government and this has led the drive to SEPERATISM – e.g. the Scottish referendum in 2014 OR the Basque case