Back to Main Back to A - level World Cities Menu
World Cities

Retailing and other services

The decentralisation of retailing and other services – causes and impacts.

Retailing is the business which involves any commercial transaction in which a buyer gains a good or service for personal, family, or household use from a shop or business.  It has undergone a transformation in the past 50 years and this has had a profound effect upon the cities in which we live.  It is a driving force for change in cities and could be seen either as an evolutionary or revolutionary force within World Cities.

 

Retailing trends Pre 1980

In the past, there was a two tier approach to retailing, based around the need for a good in terms of how frequently it was bought and its cost. There are 2 basic types of goods;

Convenience Goods: these are goods that are bought nearly everyday, readily available from the majority of shops such as milk and bread.

Comparison Goods:  these have a higher value and are purchased less often, such as household, electrical goods, clothes, shoes. People tend to go to many shops and COMPARE many products before buying them.

The result of this was that many convenience goods were bought in small local shops or local shopping centres at the butchers, grocers, bakery etc.  This allowed the development of local corner shops and local shops, to service the needs of people who just wanted to walk to get these low cost goods.  Larger CBD stores would then compete with each other to sell the more expensive comparison goods.  It is why in many shopping centres these stores AGGLOMERATE together (cluster) so that shoppers can easily compare goods, this happens with shoe shops for example. Comparison goods often involved a car ride or trip on public transport to the city centre or CBD.

 

Retailing trends Post 1980

 

Since the 1980s this type of retailing has changed fundamentally with the advent of Out of Town or edge of town retailing.  This has been made possible because;

  1. Government policies in many rich nations favoured edge of city sites and made retailing in the city centre very expensive
  2. Increased use and ownership of cars in many families
  3. Improvements to road networks, development of motorways and ring roads, making out of town sites more accessible
  4. Land prices are much cheaper at the edge of cities as shown by the Bid-rent Model.
  5. Retailers have also changed their business models and store plans, and prefer an American style of retailing with very large stores with lots of square meters of retail space, plus space for parking.

 

Hiller (1986) identified three waves of decentralisation:

  • The first involved the development of over 700 food superstores In out of centre locations from the late 1970’s to 1994;
  • The second involved the development of out of centre retail parks aimed primarily at retailers of bulky goods such as DIY, furniture and carpets;
  • And the third involved the development of out of centre regional shopping centres for comparison goods  retailers and leisure operators

 

We have seen a DECENTRALISATION then of retailing, whereby major retailers have moved there premises from central locations in the CBD to the edge of the city.  This causes the doughnut (N.America) or Polo effect (UK) where there is an economic, social and retailing hole in the middle of the city. Almost 15,000 shops in town centres in the UK closed between 2000 and 2009, with a further 10,000 losses in the past couple of years. (source) Many household names are included in that, with Woolworths and Jessops closing completely, and HMV having to be bought out.

 

Evaluation of the types of retailing;

 

Edge of town

City Centre

Positives

They are designed around easy access and parking so are consumer friendly.

They can improve the profile and status of a region of a town.

They are often covered and car free

They can provide a much needed stimulus for local and CBD retailing areas to improve

They provide a greater shopping choice, and often low prices because of economies of bulk purchasing

Increased passing-trade for some retailers

Increased employment for people who initially construct and then work in out of town shopping centres

There is room for expansion

Land prices are cheaper

They are very well connected via public transport links such as buses and trains.

They are architecturally rich areas with many historical elements, therefore offer an interesting retailing experience

Retailing areas sit alongside commerce, leisure and food outlets/uses, so consumers can profit from this.

They can have pedestrianised areas free of traffic.

Shop units are unique in shape and form

 

Negatives

They increase the reliance on car, leading to greater

pollution, increased resource use, congestion and

stress. This also disadvantages less mobile sections of the community who do not have access to this type of transport and therefore miss out on savings

When retail concentrates into few stores, a monopoly of sorts develops in which shopping choice may be restricted. In the long run, these monopolies can control prices too.

Decentralisation leads to decline of traditional town centres

Employment opportunities are mostly for females, and for part-time work.

They offer a sterile and boring shopping experience, that lacks the character and architectural riches of city centre shopping

Shop units are restricted by building size and shape and do not suit large scale retailing.

CBDs are not built for the motorcar, and therefore traffic jams can result increasing pollution levels in those areas.

Many CBDs are not covered against the weather.

Many CBDs are not pedestrianised and are therefore more dangerous.

CBDs can have higher crime rates for retailers

There is limited space for expansion

Land prices are more expensive

 

Even more recently we have had the advent of Internet shopping, and this puts even more pressure on city centre retailers.

 

Creative Commons License
Coolgeography.co.uk by Rob Gamesby is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 3.0 Unported License.

Contact - robert.gamesby@st-marys.newcastle.sch.uk
Contact via Google Docs form