Back to Main Back to A - level World Cities Menu
World Cities

Contemporary sustainability issues in urban areas

Waste management: recycling and its alternatives.

 Urban sustainability is a massive issue both in the UK and globally. It is basically to do with ensuring that cities and towns have a minimal environmental footprint (they don't pollute too much and don't consume too many natural resources) on their surrounding area, allowing local people a say so that society and communities are sustainable and making cities pleasant places to live through the provision of adequate open spaces and recreation facilities. Indeed, a sustainable city can be defined as;
""Improving the quality of life in a city, including ecological, cultural, political, institutional, social and economic components without leaving a burden on the future generations. A burden which is the result of a reduced natural capital and an excessive local debt."
Urban21 conference in Berlin 2000



However, I quite like the idea of urban sustainability as defined by the three "E's";

Economy - Economic activity should serve the common good, be self-renewing, and build local assets and self-reliance.

Ecology - Human are part of nature, nature has limits, and communities are responsible for protecting and building natural assets.

Equity - The opportunity for full participation in all activities, benefits, and decision-making of a society.

The problem of waste in cities
Human beings create an incredible amount of waste, and the problem seems to be even worse within our cities. If you think about your own home, you can consider the amount of waste that needs to be dealt with. On a weekly basis you or the council needs to deal with:
Your refuse and general waste from your bins, plastics, metals, food wastes;
Waste water from cleaning, dishwashers, washing machines;
Waste Water from your toilet;
Emissions from your energy needs.

Imagine now that this needs to be repeated for thousands of people in your town, or tens of thousands/ hundreds of thousands/millions of people in your city!
This doesn't include any of the wastes from the industrial processes that take place in cities either. In MEDCs our cities are not growing so fast or their growth has slowed, and we have had many decades to establish organised systems to get rid of our waste. In LEDCs the problem is much more difficult to deal with, especially given the rapid growth of these cities and the informal nature of some of the development, where people construct their own homes in squatter or shanty developments. One such LEDC city is Cairo. All of this ties in with the issue of
sustainability, can we continue to produce so much waste and not expect consequences?

According to the British Government we generate about 228 million tonnes of waste every year in England alone (based on 2012 figures). The UK dumps about half of its municipal rubbish into landfill sites, while Germany buries just 1% in holes in the ground.

Newcastle upon Tyne

 Every household in Newcastle has recycling bins, allowing local residents to recycle cardboard, plastics, metals and glass. In many areas there are also garden waste bins, allowing the council to produce its own compost. Local tips in Newcastle also force people to separate their waste whenever possible, further increasing recycling rates. Fires within the central area of Newcastle are banned under the Clean Air Act, improving the quality of Newcastle’s atmosphere. However, huge amounts of waste generated in Newcastle still end up in either landfill sites or incinerated.

How we deal with waste

The EU has a pyramid structure for waste management.  The methods at the top are the preferred methods and the ones at the bottom the least preferred.  They also set clear targets over waste management and countries can be fined if they fail to meet those targets.

 

What it is/how it works

Advantages

Disadvantages

Energy recovery

Energy recovery basically involves burning waste at very high temperatures to eventually reduce the amount of waste and then produce electricity. Municipal Waste is unloaded from collection trucks and placed in a rubbish storage bunker. An overhead crane is used to sort the waste and then lift it into a combustion chamber to be burned. The heat released from burning is used to convert water to steam. The steam is then sent to a turbine generator to produce electricity. The remaining ash is collected and taken to a landfill. Particulates are captured by a high-efficiency bag house (a filtering system).

It generates money. The collecting agencies get a fee, the facility makes money from selling electricity to their national grid and the sale of scrap metal collected after burning can bring in cash.

It disposes of solid, liquid and gaseous waste. It is a practical method of disposing of certain hazardous waste materials (such as biological medical waste).

Ash residue from the furnace can be processed for removal of recyclable scrap metals.

 

It generates electricity which can be used locally.

It reduces the amount of waste going into landfill.

 

There are standards in the UK to limit emissions into atmosphere of the following:

·        Sulphur Dioxide (SO2);

·        Nitrogen Oxide and Nitrogen Dioxide (NO and NO2);

·        Hydrogen Chloride (HCl);

·        Hydrogen Fluoride (HF);

·        Gaseous and vaporous organic substances expressed as Total Organic Carbon (TOC);

·        Carbon Monoxide (CO);

·        Dust;

·        Heavy Metals; and

·        Dioxins and furans;

 

Incinerators cost a lot. The upfront capital needed to build a new plant is a lot, at Hedon in Hull the cost is said to be £144 million.

The incineration process produces ash which still needs to be disposed of. This ash can be contaminated with toxins. These need special landfill for disposal.

Emissions from incinerators can include heavy metals, dioxins and furans, which may be present in the waste gases, water or ash.

The combustion of plastics, like polyvinyl chloride (PVC) gives rise to these highly toxic pollutants.

Incineration indirectly promotes continued waste generation while hindering waste prevention, reuse, composting, recycling, and recycling-based community economic development.

It costs cities and municipalities more and provides fewer jobs than comprehensive recycling and composting and also hinders the development of local recycling-based businesses.


Waste incineration systems produce a wide variety of pollutants which are Bad for human health.

Dioxins are the most lethal Persistent Organic Pollutants (POPs) which have irreparable environmental health consequences. The affected populace includes those living near the incinerator as well as those living in the broader region. People are exposed to toxics compounds in several ways:

* By breathing the air which affects both workers in the plant and people who live nearby;
* By eating locally produced foods or water that have been contaminated by air pollutants from the incinerator; and
* By eating fish or wildlife that have been contaminated by the air emissions.

Dioxin is a highly toxic compound which may cause cancer and neurological damage, and disrupt reproductive systems, thyroid systems, respiratory systems etc.

Landfill

Landfills are essentially hollows in the ground where rubbish is dumped.  Historically no real strategies were put into place to prevent environmental damage were minimal or non-existent. 

Modern landfills have linings of plastic or compacted clay to prevent leachate (a mixture of materials from the waste in the landfill and rainwater) from running out of the landfill.  This leachate is collected in pipes and transferred to leachate ponds where it can be treated to minimise damage to the environment.

Gases such as Methane that are produces as the waste decomposes are also collected and reused as fuel.

Successive layers of waste and earth are laid down, and landfills often have netting surrounding them to prevent wind blown waste escaping.

Many of the new landfills are built as lined facility with membranes or soil used to stop materials leaking, and with leachate collection and treatment on-site.

The landfill is designed and built to store waste; this is thought to be a safe containment of our waste.

Methane gas can be collected at a number of waste landfills and some landfills have diesel/gas blended fuel fired electrical generation stations built on them. This gives electricity from waste materials which are free (except for collection etc.)


Closed landfill sites can be recovered for other uses such as housing, golf courses etc.




Many older landfills that are in use are unlined. These landfills and other closed landfills are an environmental threat.  This is because they contain hazardous materials and wastes, such as lead from batteries, domestic chemicals (e.g. bleach bottles), mercury from light bulbs, and heavy metals from electronic items. Rainwater can wash these chemicals into aquifers and into our drinking water as LEACHATES.

Landfills are unattractive and reduce property prices around them. Landfills are often constructed in low lying areas and cover large areas. They attract vermin such as birds and rats. These can be controlled with birds of prey.

Landfills can smell bad! They can have some odors that can often be detected outside the bounds of the property borders.

Space for landfills is running out.

Landfills can increase traffic in more rural areas on roads that are not designed to take the heavy machines and trucks used to transport waste

Upon landfill closure, land use is extremely limited. Houses built on landfill have been known to subside.

Methane is produced which can be flammable and hazardous.

Recycling

Recycling is nothing new and can take many forms. Within our homes we take old materials and transform them into other items.  At council level or at national scale recycling becomes more important.

Large scale recycling involves used products being collected, converted back into raw materials and remade into new consumer products. These recycling plants are often very high tech, with magnets separating metals, hand recycling of other products and vents used to separate paper.

Recyclable materials include metals such as aluminum cans, paper, plastic containers, cardboard and wood are all commonly recycled often through municipal programs encouraging bulk household collections.

When a recycled good i­s cheaper or weaker than the original product, it's known as down-cycling (or downstream recycling). In some cases, goods can be up-cycled or made into something more valuable than the original product.

Recycling can lower costs for industry as there are lower manufacturing costs for products made from recycled rather than virgin materials

Countries can avoid landfill or incineration fees (as used by the EU for example.

There is inherent value in conserving our natural resources

The value of saved energy by recycling materials rather than obtaining virgin materials

It is less wasteful, as products are given extra life and there is less need to extract new raw materials.

Recycling creates employment

Recycling raises awareness of how much waste we generate, and therefore makes consumers put pressure on manufacturers to reduce packaging.

Some items can’t be down cycled forever, for example, after being recycled a few times, paper is no longer usable.

Recycling can be costly and uneconomic as collection of waste, transportation and processing costs have to be accounted for.

 
There is a need for large capital investments such as equipment, trucks, factories (processing centres), container costs and labour fees.


Recycling market fees may be charged to cover the costs of processing certain materials

Recycling requires energy and chemicals to recover the waste.

Items rich countries don’t wish to recycle, such as dangerous batteries or electronic equipment, often end up in poorer countries for processing.




Creative Commons License
Coolgeography.co.uk by Rob Gamesby is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 3.0 Unported License.

Contact - robert.gamesby@st-marys.newcastle.sch.uk
Contact via Google Docs form