Welcome to coolgeography.co.uk
Back to main Back to GCSE Development

Smaller scale aid, Sustainability and Sustainable Development

Sustainable development is "Development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs."

— From the World Commission on Environment and Development’s
(the Brundtland Commission) report Our Common Future

(Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1987).

This is one of the big concepts or ideas in Geography at the moment and links to the Environmental and Physical nature of the subject. Sustainable means an action that can be kept going for ever, something that can continue to be done without it having damaging consequences that might limit that activity in the future. This is best considered through examples. At present the human race extracts huge amount of crude oil, which is a store of carbon from the ground. We process that crude oil so that we can extract petrol and other chemicals for plastics etc. When we do so the crude oil is gone forever, and on human time scales will not be replaced. This is an UNsustainable activity, because the resource being used in NON-RENEWABLE and our use of that material has damaging consequences - Carbon Dioxide into the atmosphere and waste products such as plastic into landfill sites. Already we are living well beyond the ability of the planet to cope. You may have seen many news stories about how we are extracting too much freshwater, we have put incredible pressure on the Earth's soils, we use the ecosystem and in many cases abuse it (e.g. Tropical rainforest destruction), we have depleted fish stocks, we pollute the planet (e.g. Exxon Valdez, Carbon Dioxide emissions causing global warming), we ruin the countryside, we have extracted too much coal, oil, gas minerals etc. This does not happen evenly across the globe, some people are living more sustainable lives than others. You can calculate your ecological footprint, to see how much land area you need to sustain your lifestyle. Some of the internet calculators will even tell you how many Planet Earth's we would need if everyone lived like you!

We can make the use of crude oil MORE sustainable by recycling plastics or by driving Hybrid cars this reducing the amount of petrol used, but this is still unsustainable in the long run. To be totally sustainable we would have to not use cars that run on petrol and find alternatives to using plastics - paper bags for your fruit and vegetables for example. We could also try to use more renewable energy sources, such as wind, solar and EPH Hydro-electric power.  The Cahora Bassa dam can therefore be seen as sustainable in many respects, despite the environmental problems it caused.

It is thought by many people that LARGE-SCALE aid projects are unsustainable, and that smaller scale charity involvement and intermediate technology can have a more positive impact for people.

Voluntary aid – CAFOD in Haïti

Recall that the earthquake that hit Haïti in January 2010 killed nearly a quarter of a million and left more than a million homeless. CAFOD used public donations to help immediately. They provided tents, shelters and emergency supplies for thousands of people who had lost their homes. As people moved into camps, they built shower blocks and latrines and ensured that there were supplies of safe water. These helped in the immediate term but more needed doing to ensure that Haïti could recover its development in the longer term. According to the CAFOD website:

Today we are working with our Catholic partners to help rebuild homes and communities. Our current projects include:

Building permanent, hurricane and earthquake-resistant homes, training local engineers to lead the construction process

Helping people prepare for and manage future disasters, for example through education about hurricanes in schools or by training people in new farming techniques that reduce the risk of damage from landslide

Preventing the spread of disease. We are supporting cholera treatment centres, providing safe water and sanitation, and running hygiene awareness training

We have worked in Haiti since 1970. During that time, we have supported a wide range of development projects involving literacy, agriculture, women’s organisations and legal aid – and we have responded to emergencies.

SOURCE – CAFOD WEBSITE

Intermediate Technology and Appropriate Technology

Intermediate or appropriate technology is a move away from big aid projects.  It aims to use simpler technologies that are right for the people, right for the environment and right for the donor. In most poor countries, high tech industries are too expensive to develop and inappropriate to the needs of local people.  Appropriate/intermediate technology is usually;

A)    Labour intensive - utilising and creating employment for local labour.

B)    Using sustainable technology and tools/knowledge of local people

C)     Uses newly developed technology that are low cost and local which local people can manage and control rather than IMPORTED techniques and technologies

D)    In harmony with the local environment.

Practical Action is a charity who uses appropriate technology in a number of ways.  According to their website Practical Action's vision and mission is;

Vision - Technology justice: a sustainable world free of poverty and injustice in which technology is used for the benefit of all.
Mission
- To contribute to poor people’s wellbeing, using technology to challenge poverty by:

·         building the capabilities of poor men and women,

·         improving their access to technical options and knowledge, and

·         working with people  to influence social, economic and institutional systems for innovation and the use of technology.

 

Practical Action has over 100 projects worldwide helping over 900,000 people.  One type of project is using micro hydro-electric power stations to generate electricity so people can work their way out of poverty. Micro-hydro power is the small-scale gathering of energy from falling water, such as steep mountain rivers. Using this renewable, indigenous, non-polluting resource, micro-hydro plants can generate power for homes, hospitals, schools and workshops.

Practical Action promotes small-scale hydro schemes that generate up to 500 kilowatts of power. This provides poor communities in rural areas with an affordable, easy to maintain and long-term solution to their energy needs.
  This means that this is a great example of Appropriate Technology. They have developed micro-hydro systems with communities in Peru, Zimbabwe, Sri Lanka, and Kenya. These systems, which are designed to operate for a minimum of 20 years, are usually 'run-of-the-river' systems.

 Find out more here.

 

   
     
Think about it
Creative Commons License
Coolgeography.co.uk by Rob Gamesby is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 3.0 Unported License.