Back to Main Back to A - level Back to Globalisation
‘Economic sustainability versus environmental sustainability’.

Sustainable development has been defined by the Brundtland Report (1987) as ‘development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs’.  

 Initially, sustainability was based on environmental principles, to maintain ecological processes, life-support systems, preserve genetic diversity and ensure the sustainable use of species and ecosystems

More recently we have also considered economic sustainability, which is how countries and companies use resources optimally to achieve responsible and long term economic growth and wealth.

 The key to this issue is considering which of economic sustainability or environmental sustainability are most important, and if these 2 things are mutually exclusive of each other.

Consider the following questions;

1.      How can economic development and sustainability impact upon environmental sustainability?

2.      Can we have economic sustainability with environmental sustainability?

3.      Does economic development always have to be at the expense of the natural environment?

4.      Can economic development promote environmental sustainability?

 

Within the sustainable development process:

1.      The level of human wellbeing or potential is improved

2.      Our resource base, the natural environment is used and managed to supply people on a long-term basis

3.      Social justice is important in this concept, as well as long-term environmental sustainability

4.      Our global economy depends upon the natural environment as a source of resources and as a sink for emissions.  Our current use is unsustainable.

5.      There is the concept of overpopulation – are there too many people exploiting too many resources and producing too much pollution for natural systems to absorb?

6.      We can consider ecological footprints to measure if our economic sustainability is at the expense of environmental sustainability.

 

Economic development is often put ahead of environmental sustainability as it involves people’s standards of living.  However, quality of life can decline if people live in an economic place with a poor environmental quality because of economic development.

 

When answering questions on this topic you could use material from this website on;

1.      The very rapid growth of NICs and Asian Tigers – this has had massive impacts on the natural environment and has been unsustainable in an ecological sense.  However, this growth has lifted millions of people out of poverty so is economically sustainable. Also, the NICs do become more environmentally sustainable as time passes.

2.      Globalisation – this has increased and is predicted to continue to increase.  Again, this can provide for sustained economic development (although many LDCs are being left behind), but the mass movement of products, the demand for those products and the methods used to produce those products are highly environmentally damaging (think about rainforest destruction, exploitation of oil in the Alaskan Tundra etc. as examples).

3.      MEDCs offer the greatest insight into how a balance between economic and environmental sustainability can be sought.  Many countries including Germany and the UK are producing increasing amounts of their energy from renewables for example, and have managed to tackle environmental pollution from many of their industries through legislation.

4.      Global entities are moving us towards environmental sustainability – the UN holds climate conferences for example to try to combat the negative impacts of climate change caused by economic development.

5.      Technological innovation can move both economic and environmental sustainability forward – air miles can be cut using internet conferencing for example. Environmentally sound ideas and practises can be spread via the internet. Food can be produced in increasingly environmentally sensitive ways.

6.      Some of the poorest countries, the LDCs, suffer from both a lack of environmental sustainability and economic sustainability. This gives us the bottom billion, and need addressing.

7.      Sustainable development initiatives are promoted in many areas of life through government and NGO action – a good example of this is ecotourism.

Mumbai, India – mini case study

Mumbai is a city that has grown rapidly in both population and economically (full case study notes on Mumbai’s urbanisation here!), but is among the most polluted cities in the world. According to the WHO, Breathing Mumbai’s air is the equivalent of smoking two-and-one-half packs of cigarettes per day. The major sources are road traffic (60% of air pollution) and industry, but domestic sources make a small contribution.

Impacts of economic and urban growth on Mumbai’s environment;

 

1.      Nitrogen dioxide and carbon monoxide pollution worsened in the last part of the 20th century

2.      Particulate matter levels got worse too

3.      Atmospheric sulphur dioxide and lead declined, because of the reduced use of high sulphur fuel, especially by some major industries, and reduced lead in petrol.

4.      The maximum permissible levels of lead are sometimes exceeded because many vehicles run on leaded petrol.

5.      World Health Organisation limits for particulate pollution were exceeded in all areas and during all seasons in 1998. 97% of Mumbai’s population live in high pollution zones.

6.      The south-eastern corner of the Northern Suburbs is also affected by the burning of refuse at the 100 ha municipal garbage dump. 

7.      It has been estimated that 20m work days are lost or affected because of 24,000 cases of chronic bronchitis, 900,000 cases of asthma, and other pollution-related illnesses.

8.      Water pollution from untreated sewage and industrial waste is prevalent, and water-borne diseases are common.

9.      Improvements have been made in recent years, for example by the construction of two marine outfalls, the provision of many more standpipes and the treatment of all piped water, but water-related diseases have not declined significantly.

10.   75% of all sewage is discharged untreated into local waterways and coastal waters, and the water supply is beset by problems of low pressure and supply interruptions, allowing contamination before use.