![]() |
||
![]() |
![]() |
|
|
In the UK we are used to the advantages and disadvantages of supply food
via a globalised food network. You can buy a huge range of food stuffs from
around the World and even non seasonal items such as strawberries in the depths
of winter. This capitalist free market system has pros and cons, and is not the
only system that exists or has existed to provide food to a population on our
planet. For the demands of the AQA
course you need to learn 2 contrasting approaches to meeting the demands of food
supply. Here you will find 4
contrasting examples, you should pick 2!
The UK food production is only 60% of UK consumption
China’s Changing approach to Food supply
China’s approach to food supply has changed massively over the past 30 years.
The Communist party conference of 1978 declared Deng as leader, and he
declared a period of reform. He
wanted China’s economy to catch up with the West inside 20 years, in
agriculture, industry and technology.
His first challenge was to feed the peasants.
Chairman Mao, Deng’s predecessor, instigated People’s Communes in
agriculture, where people worked together as one community and shared the
produce with the state and between them.
This had not always worked and the great famine of 1960 killed more than
13million people and 20 years later people were still going hungry – and
population was increasing.
People in Anhui had instigated an illegal private farming system that had
increased productivity by 3 times.
In Xiao Gang people got together and divided up their land along private lines,
but were worried about reprisals.
However, Deng approved, saying “it doesn’t
matter if a cat is black or white – if it catches mice it is still a good cat”.
He meant whatever worked he would adopt.
Many people within the Communist party were against privatisation of
farming, but Deng instigated private farming through the Household
Responsibility System. It was
successful, and many areas of China became self sufficient in food production.
Farmers had to produce fixed quotas for the government and the rest was
theirs for sale. This allowed
markets to develop and cash to start to flow through rural peasant communities.
It also allowed a lot more freedom of choice - a profound change in
Chinese mentality.
Russia’s Collective system
Russia’s food production system under Communism offers a completely
different model to the capitalist free market system in which we have grown up.
When Stalin came to power with Communist rule Russia had a huge area of
land but its farms were very small, run by peasants and generally did not
produce enough food to feed the whole country.
The Communist response to this was collectivisation.
Land was seized and farms sizes increased as farms were joined together.
Organized on a large scale and
relatively highly mechanized, the Soviet Union was one of the world's leading
producers of cereals, although bad harvests (as in 1972 and 1975) necessitated
imports and slowed the economy.
Women were encouraged to work on farms and the farm workforce was educated in
more modern farming methods. Areas
were pulled together and people given COLLECTIVE responsibility for the
production of food, and technology was improved.
Tractors and other technologies were used across the country in an
attempt to raise production. In
addition, the government controlled what was grown and could order areas to
produce and give certain quantities of food to the state.
It used Terror to ensure that this happened.
This huge level of government control is very different from our system.
There are debates as to how successful Communism was in relation to
raising agricultural efficiency.
Zimbabwe and land reform
You can find out about farming in Zimbabwe at this link.
Basically, Zimbabwe went from being a net exporter of food stuffs to a
net importer of food with chronic food shortages and malnourishment of the
population within 10 years. The
link explains why. |
||